Koi are not the only fish suitable for backyard ponds. Goldfish, shubunkins, Sarasa comets, and golden orfe are popular alternatives. The best choice depends on your pond's size, climate, filtration, and available space.
Common goldfish
Common goldfish and comet goldfish are hardy, colorful fish suitable for many backyard ponds.
- Colors: Orange, red, white, and combinations of these colors.
- Care: Good for beginners and generally adaptable to outdoor pond conditions.
- Winter: Can remain outdoors in properly designed ponds with adequate depth, oxygen, and water quality.
Fancy goldfish
Fancy goldfish include orandas, ranchus, lionheads, black moors, telescopes, and ryukins.
- Appearance: Rounded bodies, distinctive fins, and unique coloring.
- Care: More delicate than common goldfish and may have difficulty competing with faster-swimming fish.
- Winter: May need to be moved indoors during colder months because they are less tolerant of harsh winter conditions.
Shubunkins
Shubunkins are hardy, single-tailed goldfish known for their colorful, calico patterns.
- Colors: Blue, red, orange, black, and white.
- Adult size: Can reach approximately 14 in. (36 cm).
- Care: Active, hardy fish suitable for outdoor ponds.
- Winter: Can overwinter in properly designed ponds that provide suitable depth and oxygen levels.
Sarasa comets
Sarasa comets are hardy goldfish recognized by their bright red-and-white coloring.
- Appearance: Slender bodies with distinctive red-and-white patterns.
- Care: Active swimmers that require adequate swimming space and filtration.
- Winter: Generally suitable for properly maintained outdoor ponds in colder climates.
Golden orfe
Golden orfe are active, fast-swimming pond fish best suited for larger ponds.
- Colors: Golden-yellow to bright orange.
- Adult size: Can reach approximately 24–30 in. (61–76 cm).
- Behavior: Prefer swimming in groups, often near the water's surface.
- Care: Require plenty of swimming space, good filtration, and well-oxygenated water.
- Feeding: Eat insects, insect larvae, and suitable pond fish food.
Important: Golden orfe are not recommended for small ponds because of their large adult size, active swimming behavior, and oxygen requirements.
Choosing the right pond fish
Before adding fish to your pond, consider:
- Pond size: Choose fish based on their expected adult size, not their size when purchased.
- Climate: Select fish capable of tolerating your local winter conditions.
- Filtration and aeration: Maintain good water quality and sufficient dissolved oxygen.
- Compatibility: Avoid keeping small or delicate fish with larger, aggressive, or much faster-swimming fish.
- Stocking levels: Avoid overcrowding and allow room for fish to grow.
For most beginners, common goldfish, shubunkins, and Sarasa comets are practical alternatives to koi.